A comparative study of the representation of Russian and British memories in the social and governmental spheres in Iran

Document Type : Research Paper

Author

Ph.D. Student in International Relation, Faculty of Law and Political Science, Allameh Tabataba'i University

Abstract

In Iran's foreign policy, the non-intervention principle is beyond the legal principle and has a fundamental aspect in Iranian philosophy and worldview in its view of the outside world. It is as if the primary function and primary concern in relation to outside borders is to combat foreign intervention, rather than cooperation or interaction. This perception has led to the formation of a phenomenon that in this study has been called “the metamemory of stranger intervention”. Two examples of the most important audience of Iranian memories in this regard are Russia and Britain. However, the foreign policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran has both extroverted and active aspects and has also established relations with the great powers and even its historical enemies according to their political, security and economic needs. The question of this research is what is Iran's politics of memory towards Russia and Britain? In response, it is said that Iran's memory policy towards Britain is based on the "politics of remembrance" of past hostilities and has full legitimacy due to consensus memories and the matching of formal and informal memory, but in relation to Russia it is based on the politics of forgetting and the use of silencing techniques and alternative narration, , but this approach has created resistance in the realm of informal memory and the attitude of inconsistency between the present orientation and the common perception of people's memories of Russia has provoked social reactions and delegitimize the development of relations with Russia.

Keywords

Main Subjects


Abrahamian, Yarvand; Ashraf, Ahmad and Homayoun Katozian, Mohammad Ali (2013), Essays on Conspiracy Theory in Iran, translated by Mohammad Ebrahim Fattahi, Tehran: Ney.
Adorno, Theodore; Hobsbawm, Eric; Saeed, Edward; Gliouch, Gram and Kilby, Jane (2017), Memory, History and Trauma, Translated by Sepideh Borzoo, Tehran: Red Wisdom.
Ariely, Gal (2019), “National Days, National Identity, and Collective Memory: Exploring the Impact of Holocaust Day in Israel”, Political Psychology, Vol. 0, No. 0.
Cherviatsova, Alina (2020), “Memory as a battlefield: European memorial laws and freedom of speech”, The International Journal of Human Rights,
Bahar, Mohammad Taghiو (2008), Poetry Divan, Tehran: Negah.
Behnoud, Massoud (2006), 275 days of 275 days of Bazargan, Tehran, Tehran: Elm.
Craik, Tulving (2020), The Oxford Handbook of Memory, Oxford University Press
Davoodi, Ali Asghar (2012), "The role of collective memory in the occurrence of ethnic conflicts", Sociology of Iran, Volume 13, Number 1-2, p. ۱۵۲- ۱۳۰.
farsi.khamenei, (11/14/1373), "Statements in Friday Prayer Sermons", available: https://khl.ink/f/2739
Farzbad, Mohammad Mehdi, Choupudasti, Haidar (1397), "Collective Memory of Generations from the Iran-Iraq War", Cultural Studies and Communication, 14th year, No. 50.
Farzbad, Mohammad Mehdi, Rezaei, Ahmad and Choobdasti, Haidar (1397), "Collective Memory and Iranian Identity", National Studies, 73, Year 19, No. 1.
Fattahizadeh, Abuzar (2016), "Politics of Memory: An Introduction to a New Approach to Politics and History", Politics, 46 (4).
IRNA (02/02/2020), "Kazem Jalali: Many in the West are reluctant to develop Iran-Russia relations", available: www.irna.ir/news/83759204/
Jaskulowski, Krzysztof (2017), “Politics of memory in Upper Silesian schools: Between Polish homogeneous nationalism and its Silesian discontents”, Memory Studies
Javadi Yeganeh, Mohammad Reza; Borzoo, Sepideh and Shahidi, Mahshid (2016), The Politics of Memory in Urban Space: A Case Study of Post-Revolutionary Museums in Tehran», Culture-Communication Study, 17 (34)
Jõesalu, Kirsti and Kõresaar, Ene (2013), “Continuity or Discontinuity: On The Dynamics of Remembering “Mature Socialism”, Estonian Post-Soviet Remembrance Culture, Journal of Baltic Studies, Vol. 44, No. 2, pp. 177–203
Karimi, Ali (2013), "Collective Memory and the Identification Process: Some Policy Reflections", National Studies, Fourteenth Year, No. 2.
Katz, Max (2013), “Sites of Memory in Hindustani Music: Yusuf Ali Khan and the Sitar Shops of Lucknow”, Ethnomusicology Forum, Vol. 23, No. 1, 67–93
Kazemi, Kazem and Mostafa Pour, Ali (2013), "The collective memory of the Kurdish people and its relationship with the attitude of the identity system", Sociology of Iran, Fourteenth Year, No. 1, pp. 172-142.
Khabaronline(19/2/2022) The document of the difference between Russia today and Russia in the Qajar period from the point of view of a member of the Foreign Policy Commission of the parliament", available: khabaronline.ir/news/1594406
Langenbacher, Eric (2010) Power and the Past Collective Memory and International Relations, Washington, D.C., Georgetown University Press
Lavinia Stan and Nadya Nedelsky, (2015) Post-Communist Transitional Justice: Lessons from 25 Years of Experience, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,
Maria Mälksoo (2017), “‘Memory Must Be Defended’: Beyond the Politics of Mnemonical Security”, Security Dialogue
Milani, Abbas (2013), ‌ the Shah, Toronto: Persian Circle.
Ram, Haggay (2000), “The immemorial Iranian nation? School textbooks and historical memory in post-revolutionary Iran”, Nations and Nationalism 6 (I), pp. 67-90.
Rasouli, Mohammad (2015), " the external relations of the Armenian Diaspora based on the concept of collective memory", Social Sciences Quarterly, Volume 25, Number 70.
Rusu Mihai, Stelian (2017), “Transitional Politics of Memory: Political Strategies of Managing the Past in Post-communist Romania”, Europe-Asia Studies,
Schudson, Michael (1997), “Lives, laws, and language: Commemorative versus non‐commemorative forms of effective public memory”, TheCommunication Review, Vol. 2(1),
Shamim, Ali Asghar (2008), Iran during the Qajar Dynasty, Tehran: Behzad
Shariati, Sara and Soroushfar, Zohreh (2016), "Study of time policy in the Iranian calendar in the years after the Islamic Revolution", Social Studies and Research in Iran / Volume 6, Number 1, p. 89-67
Snyder, Timothy (2004), The Reconstruction of Nations: Poland, Ukraine, Lithuania, Belarus, 1569–1999, New edition, Connecticut: Yale University Press
Sodaro, Amy (2018), Exhibiting Atrocity, Memorial Museums and the Politics of Past Violence, New Brunswick, Camden, and Newark, New Jersey, and London: Rutgers Universit y Press
Student News Network (2016), "Velayati: Turkmanchay also had a Persian version, but it did not have a JCPOA! / Mossadegh was optimistic about the United States and got the answer / We will maintain Iran's missile power and regions blindly in the eyes of the United States, Available: snn.ir/002t7j
Tabnak (02/16/2020), "Provincial: Opponents of Iran-Russia Relations Believe in the West", Available: tabnak.ir/004PBv
tarikhirani (04/04/2011), "The Story of Removing the Slogan of Death to the Soviet Union as Narrated by the Former Iranian Ambassador to Moscow", available: http://tarikhirani.ir/fa/news/825
Verovšek, Peter J (2016) " Collective memory, politics, and the influence of the past: the politics of memory as a research paradigm", Politics, Groups, and Identities
Verovsek, Peter J (2017), “Memory, Narrative, and Rupture: The Power of the Past as a Resource for Political Change”, Memory Studies
Wang, Zheng (2018), Memory Politics, Identity and Confict Historical Memory as a Variable, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan
Williams, Jame (2014), (Re)Constructing Memory: School Textbooks, Washington: George University
Wills, John S. (2005), “Some people even died’: Martin Luther King, Jr, the civil rights movement and the politics of remembrance in elementary classrooms”, International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education, Volume 18, Issue 1