The conceptual position of "right and good" in the dominant discourses in the Islamic Republic

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Ph.D. student in Political Science, Iranian Issues, Department of Political Science and International Relations, Faculty of Law and Political Science, South Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran.

2 Assistant Professor of Political Science, South Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran.

Abstract

The conceptual duality of good and right is one of the most basic issues of political thought,. The superiority and inferiority of these two concepts to each other has been a matter of dispute between even modern political philosophers such as Kant and Rawls. In this article, an attempt has been made to check and analyze the dominant view of the discourses of the Islamic Republic on these two concepts, and if there is one or both of them in these discourses, their precedence and backwardness are also examined. Therefore, by assuming the importance of these two concepts in looking of the political , in this article, we try to find out: How has this duality been reflected in the dominant political discourses in the Islamic Republic? Is it possible to find traces of this duality in the system of intra-discourse meanings and inter-discourse confrontations in the political field after the Islamic Revolution of Iran? The analysis method of this article is based on discourse theory. In the theoretical framework, while referring to the conceptual discussions about the duality of good and right, we have put more emphasis on John Rawls's theory of justice as fairness, which, while trying to present a combination between the categories of right and good, places logical precedence over right. The findings of the research show that the two dominant discourses of reformism/ principalism and their predecessors in the period of the Islamic Republic basically have benevolent approaches and were aimed at an idealistic goal.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

Abolhosni, Ali Mohammad (2014), Socialism, Pajoohe website, 15 November.
Abedi Ardakani, Mohammad, Azimi, Parveen (2012),  “Comparative study of the views of fundamentalist and reformist currents regarding women's political participation in the Islamic Republic of Iran (1997-2005)”, Biannual scientific Research journal Theoretical Policy Research, New period, Number 12, Autumn and Winter.
Ahmadinejad, Mahmoud (2006), Speech at the 61st session of the United Nations General Assembly, In September.
Ashraf, Ahmad and Banouzazi, Ali (2008), Social classes, government and revolution in Iran, Tehran: Nilufar Publications.
Audard, Catherine (2014), Right, Just, Good, In Dictionary of Untranslatables: A Philosophical Lexicon. Edited by Barbara Cassin, Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Azimi Dolatabadi, Amir (2008), Conflicts of political elites and political stability in the Islamic Republic of Iran. Tehran: Islamic Revolution Documentation Center.
Barzin, Saeed (1999), Political factionalism in Iran from the 1981 to May 23, 1997, Tehran: Markaz.
Bashirih, Hossein (2008), An introduction to the political sociology of Iran during the Islamic Republic, Tehran: Negahe Moaser.
Capleston, Frederick (2009), History of Philosophy (Volume 1) Greece and Rome. Translation: Seyed Jalaleddin Mojtabavi, Tehran: Scientific and Cultural.
Darabi, Ali (2007), “Iran today: fundamentalism, its nature and components”,  Zamaneh,  April 2007, number 55.
Day, John (2001), John Rawls; Theory of Justice, In the review of great political works of the 20th century, Murray Forsyth and Maurice Kinzapper, Translated by Abdul Rahman Alam. Tehran: University of Tehran.
Dehghani Firouzabadi, Jalal (2007), “The Discourse of Justice-Oriented Fundamentalism in the Foreign Policy of the Ahmadinejad Government”, Political knowledge, Spring and summer, Number 5.
Dehghani Firouzabadi, Jalal (2009), “The discourse of justice in the foreign policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran”,  Political cognition,  The first year,  Spring and summer, Number 1.
Edel,  Abraham  (2006), Right and good in the culture of the history of ideas, Translation by Translators' Collection, Vol. 2, Editor: Philip Wiener, Tehran: Saad Publication.
Ehteshami, A., M. Zweiri (2007), Iran and the Rise of its Neoconservatives: The Politics of Tehran`s Silent Revolution, London: I.B.Tauris.
Gramsci, Antonio (2005), State and civil society, Translation by Abbas Milani, Tehran: Akhtaran.
Haghighat, Seyyed Sadegh (2008), Political Science Methodology, Qom: Mofid University Publications Institute.
Harsij, Hossein & Hosseini, Seyed Motahhare (2009), “The formation of the left political current in the first decade after the revolution”, Policy Quarterly, Volume 39,  Number 3.
Hazeri, Ali Mohammad, Irannejad, Ebrahim & Mehraayin, Mustafa (2011), Islamic reformist discourse in Iran after the revolution, Encyclopaedia of Social Sciences of Tarbiat Modares (Sociology of History), third term, spring and summer.
Hosseinzadeh, Ahmed (2009), “Examination and criticism of Babi Saeed's theorizing about the Islamic Revolution of Iran”,  Amozeh magazine, Number 7.
Hosseinizadeh, Seyyed Mohammad Ali (2014), The issue of freedom in two fundamentalist and reformist discourses, Sepehr Siasat, first year, number one.
Howarth, David (1998), “Discourse”, Translated by: Ali Asghar Soltani,  Political Science Quarterly, Volume 1, Year 1, Issue 2, Autumn, Pages 156-183.
Imam Khomeini (2002), The faqih guardianship, Tehran, Institute of Set and Publication of Imam Khomeini's Works, 11th edition.
Imam Khomeini (2006), Imam will, 22-volume series, Tehran:  Imam Khomeini's Set and Publishing Institute, 4th edition.
Izadi, Rajab, Rezaee Panah, Amir (2014), “Social and economic foundations of transformation in dominant political discourses in the Islamic Republic of Iran”, Contemporary political essays, Fourth year, fourth issue, Winter.
Jorgensen, Marian & Phillips, Louise (2010),  Theory and method in discourse analysis, Translated by Hadi Jalili, Tehran: Ney Publication.
Kadi, Niki (2006),  The results of the Iranian revolution, Translated by Mehdi Haghighat Khah. Tehran: Ghoghnoos.
Khatami, Ahmad (2006), “The Quranic Foundations of the Islamic State”, Iran newspaper, special issue at the end of 2010. 16 March.
Khorramshad, Mohammad Bagher & Jamali, Javad (2018), “Political matters and political discourses in Iran after the Islamic Revolution”, Islamic Revolution Studies, Fall, No. 54.
Laclau, Ernesto & Mouffe, Chantal (1985), Hegemony and socialist strategy: Towards a Radical Democratic Politics. London: Verso.
Lialy, Mohammad Ali (2014), Political Current Studies, Volume 1, Supreme Leader's Representation Institution in Universities, Education Publishing Office.
Marsh, David & Jerry Stocker (2005), Theory and Method in Political Science, Translated by: Amir Mohammad Haji Yousefi, Tehran: Research Center for Strategic Studies.
McIntyre, Elisider (2013),  In Pursuit of Virtue: A Research in Moral Theory, Translated by Hamid Shahriary. MohammadAli Shomali. Thehran: Samt.
Mesbah Yazdi, Mohammad Taghi (1999), Political Theory of Islam, Qom: Publication Institute of Imam Khomeini Research Educational Center.
Mesbah Yazdi, Mohammad Taghi (2012), “The homeland is a contractual thing that is not worth sacrificing one's life/ The discussion of patriotism is the slogan of the era of ignorance”,   Mashreq, 2 December.   https://www.mashreghnews.ir/news/174779.
Mesbah Yazdi, M., (2005), Speech, Partov-e-Sokhan, (December 28).
Plato (2008). Plato's Banquet,  Translated by Mohammad Ali Foroughi, Tehran: Jami.
Plato (1974).  Republic, Translated by Mohammad Hasan Lotfi, Tehran: Khoshe printing house.
Quchani, Mohammad (2000),   Religious state, state religion, Tehran: Saraei.
Rabbani Khorasgani & Mirzaei (2015),   “Analysis of the Discourse Contrast of Fundamentalism and Reformism in the 10th Presidential Election”, Applied Sociology, 26th year, winter 2015, Number 4.
Rawls, John (2015), Justice as fairness, Translated by Erfan Sabeti. Tehran: Ghoghnoos.
Rawls, John (2017), A Theory of Justice, Translated by Morteza Nouri, Tehran: Nashr-e-Markaz.
Rawls, John (1988), The Priority of Right and Ideas of the Good” Philosophy & Public Affairs, Vol. 17, No. 4, Autumn, pp. 251-276.
Rawls, John (1999), A Theory of Justice. Cambridge, Mass: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.
Rawls, John (2001), Justice as Fairness: a Restatement. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.
Rawls, John (2008), Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, First published Tue Mar 25, 2008; substantive revision Mon Apr 12, 2021.  https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/rawls.
Saeed, Babi (2000), Fear Fundamentalin, translated by Gholamreza Jamshidi, Tehran: Vasfy.
Saffarian, Gholam Ali and Faramarz Motamed Dezfuli. (2008): The fall of the Bazargan government, Tehran: Qalam.
Sandel, Micheal (1998), Liberalism ad the Limits of Justice. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Sandel, Michael (a) (2018), Liberalism and its limitations, Translated by Hassan Afshar. Tehran: NaShr-e-Markaz.
Sandel, Michael (b) (2018), Justice; which work is correct?, Translated by Hassan Afshar. Tehran: NaShr-e-Markaz.
Sandel, Michael, (1995): Liberalism and its critics,  Translated by Ahmad Tadaion. Tehran: Scientific and Cultural.
Soltani, Ali Asghar (2008), Power, discourse and language: mechanisms of power flow in the Islamic Republic of Iran, Tehran: Ney Publication.
Tajik, Mohammad Reza (2011), Post-politics, theory and method, Tehran: Ney Publication.
Tajik, Mohammad Reza (2000), Secure society in Khatami's discourse, Tehran: Ney Publication.
Tajik & Roozkhosh (2008) “Investigation of the 9th Iranian presidential election from the perspective of discourse analysis”, Iran's social issues, Number 5.
Taylor, Charles (2016), Hegel and modern society, Translator: Manouchehr Haghighi Rad. Tehran: Nashr-e-Markaz
Takeye, Ray (2009), Guardian of the Revolution: Iran and the World in the Age of the Ayatollahs, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Thaler, D.E, A. Nader, Sh. Chubin, J. Green, Ch. Lynch, and F. Wehrey (2010), Mullahs, Guard, and Bonyads: An Exploration of Iranian Leadership Dynamics, Santa Monica, Calif: RAND Corporation.
Zarifinia, Mohammadreza (1999),  Autopsy of Iran's political factions: 1979 to 1999. Tehran: Azadi Andishe.
Zarshenas, Shahriar (2003), Cultural-Political Dictionary, Tehran, Political Deputy of Friday prayer Policy Council.
Research Letter of Political Science
Volume 18, Issue 1 - Serial Number 69
No.69
February 2023
Pages 7-46

Files

History

  • Receive Date: 01 October 2022
  • Revise Date: 13 December 2022
  • Accept Date: 07 January 2023

Share

How to cite

Statistics